A hunt lives or dies on what the children find. An empty plastic egg is a letdown, and a pirate chest with three coins rattling in the bottom is worse. Three packs from the favor shelf promise to fix that, each for a different date on the calendar. Skylety sells 200 pieces of pirate treasure, half gold coins and half plastic gems. OHOME sells 120 shamrock coins in green and gold for St Patrick's Day. Honoson sells a 170-piece Easter set with six kinds of favor, from silicone bracelets to sticker sheets.
They are not really rivals. One is a theme for a pirate party or a classroom prize box, one is a table decoration for March, and one is an egg-hunt kit for a whole class. What they share is the job of being found, and the questions a host asks are the same for all three. How many children does one pack cover? Will it fit in a plastic egg? And is any of it too small for the youngest guest?
That last question decides more than you might expect. The Skylety treasure is small enough that buyers return it, and the listing's own age labels contradict each other. The Honoson set is sized for children who can wear a ring and use a stamp. The OHOME coins sit in the middle, a little larger than the pirate gold and marked for ages 3 and up.
Skylety pirate treasure: 200 pieces, and every one of them small

Pirate Treasure Gold Coins and Gems Set
$9.59at our last price check
On paper this is the best deal of the three. At the price on the day we read it, 200 pieces cost under five cents each. The pack holds 100 plastic gold coins and 100 colorful plastic gems, mixed together, and the listing notes they can be sorted easily. It carries 4.3 stars from 827 ratings, with more than 300 bought in the past month.
What is in the box, and how big it is
The listing is precise about size, and it is worth reading twice. The coins are about 1 inch, or 2.5 cm, across. The gems are about 0.4 to 0.6 inch, or 1.1 to 1.4 cm. The whole pack weighs 5.44 ounces, and the detail table gives 7.09 by 7.09 by 0.63 inches for the item, which reads as the package: a flat box a little over 7 inches square holding two hundred pieces.


Lay ten coins edge to edge and they make a line about 10 inches long. The largest gem is barely more than half a coin wide. Neither number is hidden, and the size note in the bullets repeats them with a warning that the toys are small and should be played with under adult supervision. Yet size is the topic buyers mention most, 38 times, and 34 of those mentions are complaints. One buyer thought the pieces would be three times larger. Another called them much smaller than expected but still useful in a classroom.
The gap between the numbers and the photos is the whole story here. The listing's model photo shows a laughing boy lying among coins and gems, and a heap like that reads as treasure by the handful. Two hundred small pieces make a modest heap, not a pirate's floor.

Two ages and one warning
Skylety's detail table gives two ages that don't agree. The age range line says 12 years and above, while the manufacturer's recommended age is 14 months and up. For a pack of half-inch gems, those are very different promises, and buyers settle the argument themselves. All ten mentions of safety for children are negative. One parent says the gems look like candy and had to be put away for a toddler. Another says the kids could choke on them.
Public guidance is simple on this point, and the CPSC's holiday safety tips ask parents to keep small balls and toys with small parts away from children younger than 3. A half-inch plastic gem fits that description plainly. If your hunt includes toddlers, keep this pack for the older children, or use it for decoration where small hands can't reach.
Chocolate, missing gems and the mixed bag
Two odd complaints come from the listing itself. The item highlights mention chocolate gold coins, and one buyer was disappointed to find no chocolate at all. The pack is plastic, so read that phrase as a search keyword and not a description. The other complaint is about contents. A few buyers say their pack arrived with only coins, or only gems, or fewer than they expected. The treasure theme has six mentions, and four are negative. That is a small number against 827 ratings, but it is worth counting your pack when it arrives.
Where the pirate treasure does work
Buyers who planned around the size are happy. One used the pieces as part of a cake decoration and said they held up to washing. Another built a life-sized pirate treasure chest and said the items came exactly as pictured. Another filled a prize box with them, and someone else decorates little dragons. The pattern is clear. As scatter, as a chest topper or as classroom currency for older children, small is fine. As a single prize in a toddler's hunt, it isn't.
Value, and making 200 pieces look like a hoard
Value is where buyers turn hardest against this pack. Of 14 value mentions, 12 are negative, and the complaints all lead back to size. One buyer said the product should have cost half the price for a very small box of very small pieces. Another liked the quality but asked for more pieces. Those buyers paid under five cents a piece and still felt short-changed, because the heap looked smaller than the photos promised.
The fix is presentation. Small pieces look rich in a small container. A shallow bowl, a little wooden box or the top tray of a toy chest filled to the brim reads as a hoard, while the same 200 pieces at the bottom of a big plastic chest read as a handful. Sort the gems into one dish and the coins into another and the colors do more work. If the chest is big, line it with tissue or fabric first so the treasure sits near the top.
For a hunt, the coins are the better prize. They are the larger piece, they are the same color, and a child can count them. Keep the gems for the older children, for the cake or for the display, where their color shows and nobody is tempted to put one in a mouth.
What buyers say about the pirate treasure
Coins were a big hit but the gems are definitely not advised for toddlers. Had to put them away until he's older because they look like candy.Amazon buyer
“These were great quality and helped filled my prize box nicely. They are small and fit nicely into my prize containers also.”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Super cute! Used this to make a life sized pirate treasure chest decoration. The items came exactly how they looked in the pictures.”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Great to add to other coins. I used them in a pirate chest and they work fine. If you’re looking for larger coins these are not them.”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“This is not the traditional size coins - these are tiny and not suitable for young kids. We had to return them.…”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Didn’t come as advertised. Received gold coins but NONE of the jewels”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“This product should have cost half the price. Very small box with very small coins and gems. Very disappointed.”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
| Topic | Reviews that mention it | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 25 | 18 | 7 (28%) |
| Appearance | 15 | 12 | 3 (20%) |
| Functionality | 7 | 7 | 0 (0%) |
| Treasure | 6 | 2 | 4 (67%) |
| Size | 38 | 4 | 34 (89%) |
| Value for money | 14 | 2 | 12 (86%) |
| Safety for children | 10 | 0 | 10 (100%) |
Topic counts as Amazon groups them on the product page, read November 18, 2026.
The star split carries 8% one- and two-star ratings and another 12% three-star, the weakest profile in this roundup. The theme table explains it. Quality is mostly kind at 18 of 25, appearance at 12 of 15 and usefulness at 7 of 7. Then size, value and safety turn sharply negative: 34 of 38, 12 of 14 and 10 of 10. Read together, the buyers are saying the treasure is pretty and well made but smaller than the price led them to expect.
OHOME St Patrick's coins: 120 shamrocks in green and gold

Gold Coins St Patricks Day
$11.99at our last price check
OHOME's coins are a different kind of treasure. They are a table decoration first, a party favor second, and the gold at the end of a St Patrick's rainbow before either. The pack holds 120 plastic coins, 60 green and 60 gold, each embossed with a three-leaf clover on both sides and the words Happy St. Patrick's Day. At the price on the day we read it, that is about 10 cents a coin.
Size and finish
On size, the detail table gives the item dimensions as 1.4 by 1.4 by 0.1 inches, which reads as the size of one coin, although the listing doesn't say so directly. If that is right, each OHOME coin is about four-tenths of an inch wider than a Skylety coin. The pack weighs 0.17 kg. The bullets describe durable, reusable plastic and color that won't fade easily, which is the seller's claim and nothing more.


Printing on both sides matters for a scatter. A coin that lands face down still shows a shamrock, so a handful thrown across a tablecloth looks finished without anyone turning them over. The two colors help too. Sixty green and sixty gold give you an even mix for a table, or two teams for a coin hunt.
The detail table gives an age of 3 years and up. That is the same floor the CPSC uses for small parts, and a coin about 1.4 inches across, if that figure is the coin, is still a small object. Keep the bowl off the low table if a crawling baby is at the party.
What the listing leaves out
For a decoration this simple, the OHOME product page says surprisingly little. There is no description, no size line in the bullets and no note on how the coins are packed, so you can't tell from the listing whether the two colors arrive mixed or in separate bags. Nothing is said about the finish beyond a shiny appearance, and nothing about whether the gold is printed or a metallic plastic. None of that is a fault in the coins. It simply means the photos are doing most of the selling, and the 172 ratings are your only check that the photos are fair.
What the coins are for
Table decorations, photo props and party favors are the uses the listing suggests. The photos show coins spilling from a pot next to a green hat and stacked in front of a couple wearing shamrock props, which is the obvious St Patrick's picture. A pot of gold at the end of a classroom hunt is the other natural use. Hide them around the room, and the child who finds the most green coins picks the next game.


What you won't get is a year-round prop. These coins carry a date on their face, so they belong to one week of March. If you want gold coins for a pirate party in summer, they are the wrong pack, and the Skylety treasure or a plain gold coin set would serve better.
After the party
The listing calls the coins durable and reusable, and that is the likeliest way to get value from them. At about 10 cents each, 120 coins are cheap enough to give away by the handful, but they are also easy to sweep back into the bucket at the end of the evening and keep for next March. A zip bag in the holiday box is all the storage they need.
A classroom gets the most mileage from them. Sixty coins of each color split a class into two teams, and five coins a child at 24 children uses the pack exactly. If you use them as a hunt reward, decide in advance whether children keep the coins or return them, because a coin that says Happy St. Patrick's Day is a souvenir to a small child.
What buyers say about the shamrock coins
There are no buyer excerpts or topic counts on this listing, so the evidence is the star chart alone. It shows 4.6 stars from 172 ratings, with 77% five-star and only 3% one- and two-star. Another 12% sit at three stars, which suggests a group of buyers who found the coins fine but unremarkable. The listing shows no monthly sales figure. A small, quiet listing with good marks is a reasonable bet for a seasonal decoration, but we can't tell you what buyers liked or disliked, because the product page doesn't show their words.
Honoson Easter favors: 170 pieces in six kinds

170 Piece Easter Party Favors Set Bulk Easter Egg Fillers Stuffed, Multicolour
$15.99at our last price check
This is the egg-hunt kit of the three, and it is built around a class of 24. The bullets list 24 silicone bracelets, 24 stampers, 50 sheets of stickers, 24 cookie bags, 24 rings and 24 badges, totaling 170 pieces. At the price on the day we read it, that is under 10 cents a piece, or about 67 cents for each child's share. The listing carries 4.6 stars from 53 ratings.
What is in the box
The characters are classic Easter: bunnies, chicks, a duck and more, in several colors and styles. The bracelets and rings are soft silicone, the stickers are paper, and the bags are cellophane with metallic twist ties, which the description says seal without adhesive. The badges are pins, and the material line lists metal alongside paper, plastic and silicone, which is worth knowing before you hand one to a small child.



One number doesn't line up. The bullets and description add up to 170 pieces, and 24 times five plus 50 sticker sheets does make 170. The detail table, though, says 194. The difference is exactly 24, which might be the twist ties counted separately, but the listing doesn't say. Plan on 170.
The description gives no sizes, only a line saying size is as the pictures show and that manual measurement allows for slight errors. That is a gap if you are filling eggs, because you can't check from the listing whether a stamper fits inside a standard plastic egg. Rings, bracelets and a folded sticker sheet are the safe guesses. Test the stamper and the badge in one egg before you buy a hundred eggs.
Ages and pins
Honoson gives a manufacturer's recommended age of 8 years and up. That is the highest age floor of the three packs and it fits the contents: stampers, pins and small silicone rings. For a hunt with younger children, the CPSC's small-parts guidance applies to the rings, and a pin is a pin. One buyer was happy with the set except for the pins, without saying why. If your hunters are mostly under 8, keep the badges for the grown-ups and let the bracelets and stickers carry the hunt.

Stickers steal the show
Of the six favors, the stickers get the warmest single comment. One buyer said they were surprisingly the biggest hit, and with 50 sheets for 24 children, every child can have two, with two sheets left over. The listing also suggests using them to decorate Easter eggs, which turns a favor into an activity for the minutes after the hunt, when children are sitting on the grass with their baskets.
Packing 24 bags
The set is laid out for a class of 24, so bagging it is mostly counting. Each child's bag takes one bracelet, one stamper, one ring, one badge and two sticker sheets, which leaves two sheets spare for the child who tears one. The 24 cookie bags close with the metallic twist ties, so you need no tape.
Set up a line on the kitchen table: bags open in a row, then one pile of each favor, then the stickers last so they lie flat on top. Count the piles before you start. If a pile is short, you will know before the last three bags rather than after, and you can fill the gap with something from the cupboard.
For a hunt rather than a bag handout, split the set across eggs. Rings and bracelets go one to an egg, stickers fold into another, and the stampers and badges become the bigger prizes hidden in the harder spots. Six kinds of favor give you a natural way to make every egg feel different, which matters on an Easter morning with a lot of eggs.
What buyers say about the Easter set
Great assortment for a large family Easter egg hunt! Good value - the kids (and adults) enjoyed the little tidbits.Amazon buyer
“Cute goodie bag set, Worthy !”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Items quality are good! But Missing toys (24Horns). Disappointed”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“I was happy with this set with the exception of the pins.…”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“…The stickers were surprisingly the biggest hit! Would recommend and will buy again!”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“…Everything is good quality. Worth the price!”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
| Topic | Reviews that mention it | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 11 | 10 | 1 (9%) |
| Value for money | 5 | 5 | 0 (0%) |
Topic counts as Amazon groups them on the product page, read November 18, 2026.
With 53 ratings, this is a small sample, and the score should be read that way. The split is clean, though: no one-star ratings, 4% two-star, 78% five-star. Quality mentions are 10 of 11 positive and value mentions 5 of 5. The one sour note is a buyer who says 24 horns were missing, which doesn't match anything on the listing's contents list. Count your pieces against the list on arrival, and you will know quickly whether your box is complete.
How many children one pack covers
The three packs come in different counts and break down differently. The table uses the stated counts and the prices on the day we read them. Cost per child assumes a group of 24.
| Pack | Pieces | Price | About per piece | Share for each of 24 children | About per child |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Skylety pirate treasure | 100 coins, 100 gems | $9.59 | under 5 cents | 4 coins and 4 gems, 8 pieces left | 40 cents |
| OHOME shamrock coins | 60 green, 60 gold | $11.99 | 10 cents | 5 coins | 50 cents |
| Honoson Easter favors | 170 in six kinds | $15.99 | under 10 cents | 1 bracelet, stamper, ring, badge, bag and 2 sticker sheets | 67 cents |
Honoson's share is the most generous for a hunt, because each child gets six different things instead of a handful of one. The Skylety share is the most pieces for the least money, which is what you want for a chest you fill and pour. The OHOME coins split the difference, five coins each, all the same theme.
For a hunt you plan by eggs rather than children, think in fillings. The next table shows how many eggs one pack fills if each egg holds one item, or a small handful.
| Pack | One item per egg | Eggs at a handful each | Best filler |
|---|---|---|---|
| Skylety pirate treasure | 200 eggs | 50 eggs at 2 coins and 2 gems | coins for older children |
| OHOME shamrock coins | 120 eggs | 40 eggs at 3 coins | gold coins at the end of the rainbow |
| Honoson Easter favors | 146 items plus 24 bags | 24 eggs with one of each small piece | rings, bracelets and folded stickers |
Those egg counts are arithmetic, not a promise of fit. None of the three listings states the size of egg it fits, and only the Skylety listing gives sizes at all. Test one egg with your fullest handful before you fill the rest.
Running the hunt on the day
Every hunt has the same three risks: the little ones find nothing, the big ones find everything, and something small ends up in the wrong mouth. The packs in this roundup can help with all three if you sort them before the first egg is hidden.
Split by age first. Fillers with the smallest pieces, the Skylety gems, the Honoson rings and the badges with their pins, go into eggs for the older children, hidden higher and further away. The larger, flatter pieces, the OHOME coins, the stickers and the bracelets, go into eggs at toddler height in plain sight. That way the youngest guests reach only what suits them, and the CPSC guidance on small parts is followed by the layout of the garden rather than by a grown-up on guard duty.
Then count. Decide how many eggs each child should find, multiply by the number of children, and check that against the egg table above. A short hunt is worse than a long one, and a few spare eggs in a pocket rescue the child who comes back with an empty basket. Finally, keep the opened packaging until the hunt is over. If a buyer's story of missing pieces turns out to be your story, you will want the box to compare against.
How the three compare
| Skylety Pirate Treasure Gold Coins and Gems Set | OHOME Gold Coins St Patricks Day | Honoson 170 Piece Easter Party Favors Set Bulk Easter Egg Fillers Stuffed, Multicolour | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $9.59 | $11.99 | $15.99 |
| Amazon rating | 4.3 (827) | 4.6 (172) | 4.6 (53) |
| Material | Crystal,Gems,Plastic | Plastic | Metal, Paper, Plastic, Silicone |
| Item Weight | 5.44 ounces | 0.17 kg | n/a |
The side-by-side shows three packs aimed at different ages. Honoson says 8 and up, OHOME says 3 and up, and Skylety says both 14 months and 12 years. The materials differ just as much: plastic coins and gems, plain plastic coins, and a mix of silicone, paper, plastic and metal pins. Only Skylety publishes measurements, and only Honoson includes the bags.
Price tells its own story. The Skylety box costs the least and gives the most pieces, the OHOME coins sit in the middle, and the Honoson set costs the most but is the only one that covers a class with six different things. Per child, the gap between them is a matter of cents. Per hunt, the difference is whether the children open eggs full of one thing or full of surprises, and that is the case for paying a little more.
| Product | Price | Rating | Ratings | Bought last month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Skylety Pirate Treasure Gold Coins and Gems Set | $9.59 | 4.3 | 827 | 300+ |
| OHOME Gold Coins St Patricks Day | $11.99 | 4.6 | 172 | n/a |
| Honoson 170 Piece Easter Party Favors Set Bulk Easter Egg Fillers Stuffed, Multicolour | $15.99 | 4.6 | 53 | n/a |
| 132 Pcs Party Favors Toys for Kids 4-8 | $11.99 | 4.5 | 291 | 100+ |
| 126 Pcs Pop Party Favors for Kids | $11.99 | 4.5 | 1,322 | 5K+ |
| 35Pcs Animal Erasers Desk Pets for Kids | $8.98 | 4.6 | 8,843 | 1K+ |
| Play-Doh 50-Pack Refill Color Sticks | $11.49 | 4.9 | 202 | 10K+ |
| KINGYAO Squishies Squishy Toy 24pcs Party Favors for Kids Mochi… | $9.99 | 4.6 | 23,838 | 1K+ |
Prices, ratings and monthly purchase counts as shown on Amazon search results on November 18, 2026. Highlighted rows are the products reviewed here.
Against the wider field, the Honoson set holds up. The 132-piece and 126-piece toy assortments in the search cost less than the Honoson box, sit at 4.5 stars and have more ratings. They bring a wider mix of toys, and one names Easter egg fillers in its title, but neither title mentions bags. If the date on the calendar doesn't matter, they are worth a look.
The animal erasers carry 4.6 stars from 8,843 ratings and cost less than any of our three, though 35 pieces won't fill many eggs. The Play-Doh 50-pack has the best rating in the table at 4.9, from 202 ratings, and costs less than the Honoson set, so it is the obvious upgrade for a hunt where each child finds one premium item.
KINGYAO's mochi squishies show up in this search too, as a 24-pack at a lower price than the Honoson box. The listing says they fit in regular plastic eggs, and our review of the 24-pack of mochi squishies covers why buyers love them and why some find them grubby within days.
Which one for which hunt
| Hunt or party | Our pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Easter egg hunt for a class of 24 | Honoson Easter favors | Six favors per child and the bags to carry them |
| Family Easter hunt with toddlers | Honoson, without the badges and rings | The pins and small rings belong with older children |
| St Patrick's classroom pot of gold | OHOME shamrock coins | Two colors, two-sided print, five coins a child |
| St Patrick's table scatter | OHOME shamrock coins | A shamrock shows whichever side lands up |
| Pirate chest decoration | Skylety pirate treasure | 200 pieces for pouring and display |
| Pirate party for older children | Skylety coins, gems kept back for the oldest | Buyers find the gems too small for little ones |
| Prize box for a classroom | Skylety pirate treasure | A buyer found them a good fit for prize containers |
For goodie bags to pair with the hunt, our roundup of bubble wands, jelly bracelets and scrunchies covers three cheap fillers that sit well next to an egg or a coin. If the Honoson cookie bags aren't enough, our review of popcorn, strawberry, Valentine and kraft treat bags and the comparison of organza, canvas and muslin favor bags look at the options.
Who should buy which, and who should skip
Buy the Honoson set if you are running an Easter egg hunt or making Easter bags for a class of 24 school-age children. It is the only pack here that does the whole job alone, from favors to bags. Skip it for a crowd of toddlers unless you remove the pins and rings, and skip it outside Easter, because the bunnies and chicks date it.
The OHOME coins suit a St Patrick's table, a classroom pot of gold or a March party for children 3 and up. They are the cleanest-looking of the three and the easiest to scatter. Skip them if you want buyer reports before you buy, because there are none, or if you need coins for any other month.
Pick the Skylety treasure if you are filling a display chest, decorating a cake, stocking a prize box or running a pirate game for older children. Two hundred pieces go further than anything here per dollar. Skip it if your guests are under 3, or if you pictured big, heavy pirate coins: the listing says 1 inch, and buyers confirm the pieces are every bit that small.
Each brand has its own site. Skylety lists this pirate treasure set among its favors and party supplies. OHOME builds its range around the calendar, from Christmas to St Patrick's Day. Honoson shows its 170-piece Easter set among its seasonal goods. More ideas for bags and baskets live in our favors and goodie bags section.
Verdict
We recommend the Honoson Easter set for egg hunts: six kinds of favor for 24 children, bags included, at about 67 cents a child, from a small but happy group of buyers. The OHOME shamrock coins are a pleasant March decoration with good marks but no buyer comments to judge by, so they come with that caveat. We don't recommend the Skylety pirate treasure for young children. It is honest about its size, but buyers still find it tiny, the gems are a choking risk, and the listing contradicts itself on age. For a display chest or older hunters, it does the job cheaply.
The Easter set wins, the pirate coins need older hunters
For an egg hunt, the Honoson set is the one to buy: six kinds of favor for 24 children in one box. The OHOME shamrock coins are a pleasant St Patrick's table scatter with little buyer evidence behind them. The Skylety pirate treasure works as decoration and for older children, but buyers find it tiny and the gems a choking risk for little ones.
- Honoson covers 24 children with a bracelet, stamp, ring, badge, bag and two sticker sheets each
- OHOME coins are printed on both sides in green and gold, 60 of each
- Skylety gives 200 pieces of pirate treasure for well under five cents each
- Skylety coins are about 1 inch and gems under 0.6 inch, and 34 of 38 size mentions are complaints
- Skylety's own detail table lists two different ages, and buyers call the gems a choking hazard
- OHOME has no buyer excerpts at all, and Honoson's 53 ratings are a small sample
Best for: Easter egg hunts for school-age children, St Patrick's tables and pirate-themed decor
Skip it if: Your hunters are toddlers, or you expect chunky, palm-sized pirate coins
Where the numbers come from. Prices, star ratings, rating counts and monthly purchase badges were read from the product pages on November 18, 2026; they move daily. Counts, sizes and materials come from the product specifications. Buyer quotes are Amazon reviews as the product page shows them, linked to the full review where Amazon gives one. See how we review.




