Independent reviews for parties, holidays and gifts96 reviews · 252 products · 30 brands

Balloons, favors, holiday decor, gift boxes and the bulk packs behind every party, read before you buy.

Events & CelebrationsThe party review desk
Menu

Game Day & Outdoor Events · Head to head

One Michigan team lanyard or a 20-pack of cruise lanyards with card sleeves

Both sit at 4.7 stars; the Hotop pack puts a strap and a clear sleeve on 20 people for about 90 cents each, the Michigan strap is one licensed piece.

One Michigan team lanyard or a 20-pack of cruise lanyards with card sleeves
A couple wearing the Hotop cruise lanyards on a boat deck, from the listing photos.

Someone in your group is going to carry a ticket, a cabin key or a badge around their neck all day, and the real question is whether that strap should say who they cheer for or simply keep twenty people's cards from going missing. These two products answer different halves of that question. The Desert Cactus University of Michigan Lanyard is one navy strap printed with the Wolverines mark, fitted with a snap buckle and a metal clasp, and sold one at a time. The Hotop 20 Pack Cruise Lanyards is a bag of twenty printed polyester straps, each paired with a clear PVC sleeve sized for a ship card.

They turn up on the same search page, and both hold 4.7 stars from a little over three hundred ratings: 332 for the Michigan strap, 323 for the Hotop pack. So the stars won't choose for you. What decides it is the head count, and whether anyone needs a sleeve. One fan who wants keys and a work badge on a Michigan strap is a different buyer from the person organizing a family cruise, a reunion weekend or a tailgate crew where every pass has to stay dry and visible.

We read both listings, their detail tables, the photos and what buyers wrote about each, and set them side by side below. If you are kitting out a whole day outside, the rest of our game day and outdoor picks sit in one place.

Meet the two lanyards

University of Michigan Lanyard
Desert Cactus

University of Michigan Lanyard

4.7 / 5 from 332 ratings100+ bought last month

$11.99at our last price check

Check price on Amazon

The Michigan lanyard comes from Desert Cactus, a Chicago company that describes itself on the listing as holding licensing agreements with professional leagues and hundreds of colleges. The listing states that this lanyard is officially licensed for the Michigan Wolverines, and that Desert Cactus pays royalties for the marks. That is the whole point of buying it: the strap is a piece of team gear, not a utility item. The brand also sells flags, keyrings and plate frames for the same schools on the Desert Cactus site, and we looked at a few of those pieces in our team keyrings, hats and flags review.

Cruise Lanyards with ID Holders, 20-pack
Hotop

Cruise Lanyards with ID Holders, 20-pack

4.7 / 5 from 323 ratings

$17.99at our last price check

Check price on Amazon

The Hotop pack is the opposite kind of purchase. Nobody's team is on it. You get twenty straps in assorted printed patterns and twenty clear sleeves, and the listing aims it squarely at cruise groups: ship cards, cabin keys, boarding passes, shore days. Hotop sells a long list of multi-piece packs, from jelly bracelets to curtain rings, on its own site, and this pack fits that habit of selling in bulk for a crowd.

The two listings side by side
Desert Cactus University of Michigan LanyardHotop Cruise Lanyards with ID Holders, 20-pack
Price$11.99$17.99
Amazon rating4.7 (332)4.7 (323)
MaterialPolyesterPlastic
Closure typen/aBuckle
Item Weight1 ounces16 ounces
Package Dimensions11.46 x 3.46 x 0.39 inches; 1 ouncesn/a

What is in each box

The Michigan strap: one lanyard, no sleeve

The Desert Cactus box holds one lanyard. The detail table gives one item, polyester, a snap fastener and a weight of 1 ounce. The bullets describe a detachable plastic snap buckle, so you can pull your keys or ID off without lifting the strap over your head, plus a metal clasp at the end for the keyring or badge. The strap is 0.75 inches wide and 20 inches long end to end, by the listing's measure. The listing doesn't say whether that 20 inches is the full strap laid flat or the drop when it hangs, so read it as a guide rather than a promise of where the clasp lands on your chest.

What it does not include matters more than what it does. There is no card sleeve. If you want to carry a game ticket, a parking pass or a printed name card on this strap, you need a separate badge holder to hang from the clasp. For keys and a hard plastic work badge with a punched hole, it is ready to go out of the box. One more listing detail, written plainly because it puzzled us: the detail table lists the pattern as "Floral," which the photos don't show. The pictures show a solid navy strap with the Michigan block M printed along it.

The stitching, the listing says, is reversed on purpose so the design faces out when worn. That is a small thing, and it is the sort of small thing that separates a fan strap from a generic one: the logo shows on both sides of your neck rather than flipping to the plain back.

The Hotop pack: twenty straps, twenty sleeves

The Hotop pack holds 20 lanyards and 20 card holders. According to the description, the straps are polyester and nylon, 43.31 inches long and 0.79 inches wide (110 by 2 cm), and the sleeves are PVC at 4.41 by 2.68 inches (112 by 68 mm). Each strap has a quick-release buckle, the same idea as the Michigan one: the card comes off while the strap stays on. The whole pack weighs 16 ounces, which works out to under an ounce per set.

The straps come in assorted printed patterns. The listing calls the colors "assorted" and says the shade may differ a little from the photos, so you can't order twenty of one pattern. Several buyers treat that as a feature: when every card on the ship looks alike, a different strap tells you whose card is whose before you squint at the name. The description adds one caution in the seller's own words: "Risk of entanglement may exist, please keep away from little kids." Take that seriously if small children are in the group. A strap around a toddler's neck is a different matter from a strap on a teenager.

The seller's video of the Hotop cruise lanyards · Video: Hotop

Sizes, counts and what they cost per person

The Michigan strap is priced as a gift. The Hotop pack is priced as a supply run. At the prices on the day we read the listings, one Michigan strap at $11.99 costs about as much as 13 Hotop sets (11.99 divided by 0.90), and the Hotop pack at $17.99 works out to about 90 cents for each strap and sleeve (17.99 divided by 20).

Desert Cactus MichiganHotop cruise pack
Price$11.99$17.99
Pieces1 strap20 straps, 20 sleeves
Cost per strapthe full priceabout $0.90 with a sleeve
Strap width0.75 in0.79 in
Strap length as listed20 in end to end43.31 in
Card sleevenonePVC, 4.41 x 2.68 in
Weight1 oz16 oz for the pack
Releasesnap buckle plus metal claspquick-release buckle

The widths are almost the same, a twenty-fifth of an inch apart, so neither strap will feel noticeably heavier or wider on the neck. The lengths are the puzzle. The two listings may not measure the same way, and we can't tell from the pages whether the Michigan figure is a folded or a hanging measure. If length matters to you (a tall guest, a heavy coat on a cold tailgate), the Hotop page gives the clearer number.

How many packs for your group

Here is the Hotop pack translated into group sizes. The cost per guest uses the price on the day we read it.

GuestsPacksSpare setsAbout per guest
8112$2.25
1416$1.29
2010$0.90
25215$1.44
4020$0.90

The arithmetic is simple: 17.99 divided by the head count for one pack, 35.98 divided by the head count for two. One buyer used fourteen sets on a family cruise and kept the rest. Another bought for a family cruise of more than twenty members. A third orders several sets at a time to hand to cruise clients. Spares are not wasted, either: a lost card sleeve on day three is the most ordinary problem a group trip has.

For the Michigan strap, the math is one strap, one person. Six Wolverines fans at a tailgate means six straps at six times the price on the card, a little over $70 at the price on the day we read it. Nobody buys it that way. It is a stocking stuffer, a graduation add-on or a gift for the one alumnus in the family, and the listing pitches it exactly like that.

Setting up and how they hold up

Michigan: ready for keys, and the clasp is the question

Setup is nothing: clip your keys or badge to the metal clasp and wear it. The snap buckle lets you hand your keys to the valet or tap your badge at a reader without taking the strap off. One buyer who works in retail keeps a badge on it every day.

Holding up is where the Michigan strap gets mixed reports. Buyers mention durability nine times, and six of those mentions are negative. Two buyers had the metal clip fail, one within a month, and one reports the fabric starting to shred. Weigh that against the size of the sample. Only 3% of all ratings are one or two stars (2% and 1%), and 83% are five stars, so most owners are happy. But the complaints cluster on one part, the clasp, which is the part that takes the strain of keys yanked from a pocket all day. If you plan to hang a heavy key ring off it every day, expect to watch the clip. If it carries a badge to a few games and a graduation, the odds look better.

Hotop: slide in the card, and treat the sleeves as consumables

Hotop setup takes a minute per person: thread the sleeve onto the buckle, slide in the card, hand it over. One buyer wrote that everything was easy to assemble. The clear PVC front is the reason to buy it. Crew can scan the card through the sleeve, and the quick-release lets you pass the card across a counter without handing over your strap.

Durability comes up eleven times in Hotop reviews, seven positive and four negative. The praise is specific: straps that held up through a seven-day voyage, fourteen sets that all survived a family cruise. The complaints are about the sleeves rather than the straps. One buyer calls the clear badge holders flimsy, another had some plastic rip "because the kids are ruff," and one found an ID holder missing and a lanyard damaged in one of three sets. A buyer sums up the honest expectation: the clip works well, but "its plastic so they won't last for multiple cruises." For a one-week trip with spares in the bag, that is fine. For a strap you want to keep for years, it isn't the product.

Neither listing claims the sleeves or straps are made for water sports. Hotop's bullets say the clear sleeves help shield cards from splashes and poolside moisture; that is the extent of the claim.

What buyers say

Desert Cactus Michigan lanyard

4.7

332 Amazon ratings
100+ bought in the past month

5 star83%
4 star9%
3 star5%
2 star1%
1 star2%

Distribution of Amazon star ratings for the University of Michigan Lanyard, read on November 18, 2026.

I get a lot of compliments, especially from people from Michigan, I am a Michigan native and live in Texas.Amazon buyer

The appearance mentions are all positive, five of five. Buyers say it looks as photographed and wears well as a gift, with two of them buying for sons. Quality mentions are 14 positive out of 16. The trouble is all in durability.

Amazon customer reviewOn quality

“Bought as a gift and the recipient loved it. The lanyard is well made and looks just as depicted in the photo.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn appearance

“…I get a lot of compliments, especially from people from Michigan, I am a Michigan native and live in Texas.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn durability

“This is sturdy for badges and keys. I work in retail and have my badge attached to it.…”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn durability

“Metal clip Snapped completely in half after pulling on it just a little”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn durability

“…The fabric is already starting to shred. This is not the best quality.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

What University of Michigan Lanyard owners write about
TopicReviews that mention itPositiveNegative
Quality16142 (13%)
Appearance550 (0%)
Durability936 (67%)

Topic counts as Amazon groups them on the product page, read November 18, 2026.

Hotop cruise lanyards

4.7

323 Amazon ratings

5 star82%
4 star11%
3 star3%
2 star2%
1 star2%

Distribution of Amazon star ratings for the Cruise Lanyards with ID Holders, 20-pack, read on November 18, 2026.

Used fourteen of them on a family cruise. Perfect fit for key cards. Sturdy and all of them survived the cruise in one piece.Amazon buyer

The Hotop pack is the rare listing where the praise and the complaints point at the same detail. Buyers love the quick-release clip (seven mentions, all positive) and the colorful straps that tell cards apart (five of five). The only real negatives are about the plastic sleeves and the odd missing piece. Quality mentions run 30 positive to 1 negative out of 31, and 82% of ratings are five stars.

Amazon customer reviewOn portability

“Great for our key cards for our cruise. Easily remove card at clip to pass for purchases, if needed. Easily scan card as room key.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn sturdiness

“Used fourteen of them on a family cruise. Perfect fit for key cards. Sturdy and all of them survived the cruise in one piece.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn durability

“…Everyone loved them! They held up perfectly the entire 7 days of our voyage. I can even use it again next year.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn quality

“Item was great. Only complaint is one ID holder was missing and one lanyard was damaged. I ordered 3 sets and have only opened one so far.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn sturdiness

“The badge holders are very flimsy. The lanyards are ok but the clear badge holders are cheap and not durable at all.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

Amazon customer reviewOn detachable clip

“…The necklace did well to detach and reattach easily but its plastic so they won't last for multiple cruises.”

Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.

What Cruise Lanyards with ID Holders, 20-pack owners write about
TopicReviews that mention itPositiveNegative
Quality31301 (3%)
Functionality990 (0%)
Portability880 (0%)
Detachable clip770 (0%)
Color options550 (0%)
Design550 (0%)
Sturdiness541 (20%)
Durability1174 (36%)

Topic counts as Amazon groups them on the product page, read November 18, 2026.

Was a great gift for my clients going on a cruise, some of the plastic ripped because the kids are ruff.Amazon buyer

Read that last quote twice. A travel agent bought these as gifts and still recommends them, while telling you plainly that children are hard on the sleeves. That is about as useful as a buyer review gets.

How they compare with other lanyards

How it compares
ProductPriceRatingRatingsBought last month
Desert Cactus University of Michigan Lanyard$11.994.7332100+
Hotop Cruise Lanyards with ID Holders, 20-pack$17.994.7323n/a
Koorito 3 Pack Clear ID Badge Holder with Lanyard$4.594.63,35210K+
50 Pack Name Tag Lanyards with ID Holders$16.994.4315300+
10 Pack Lanyard Card Holders for Vertical ID Badges$7.794.6446700+
4x3 Name Tags Badge Holder with Lanyard 50 Pack Waterproof Horizontal…$25.954.75681K+
Retractable ID Badge Holder with Breakaway Lanyard$8.984.52,9855K+
12 Pack Lanyards for ID Badges Cruise Lanyard for Ship Cards$7.994.62,202n/a
Lanyard with ID Holder 50 Pcs Waterproof Name Tag Vertical Badge ID…$23.994.71,153300+
100Pcs Black Lanyards for ID Badges with Name Tags Badge ID Card…$18.894.5570400+
2-Pack Badge Holder Retractable Clip Heavy Duty Carabiner Badge Reel$9.984.65,26210K+
MNGARISTA 2-Pack Retractable Keychain$13.994.433,38810K+

Prices, ratings and monthly purchase counts as shown on Amazon search results on November 18, 2026. Highlighted rows are the products reviewed here.

The search for "lanyard with id holder" turns up mostly bulk badge packs and retractable reels, and the table shows where each of our two sits among them.

Against the bulk packs, the Hotop pack is not the cheapest way to put a sleeve on a neck. The 50-pack of black name tag lanyards and the 100-piece black lanyard set both cost less per piece than Hotop, and the 12-pack of colored cruise lanyards costs less per pack, with eight fewer straps. What Hotop sells against them is pattern and color. The black conference sets are built for an office event where every badge should look the same. A cruise or a reunion wants the opposite.

Against the retractable reels and carabiner badge holders, the Michigan strap is a different object altogether. One of those reels has more than thirty thousand ratings, and their titles pitch them at nurses and officers who badge in all day. The Michigan strap sells to fans. If you want a work badge to survive daily pulling, a heavy-duty reel is the tool, and the Michigan strap is the decoration. That said, the Desert Cactus strap holds its rating with 332 reviews and an 83% five-star share, which is a match for the bulk packs in satisfaction.

The closest rival to Hotop is the 12-pack of cruise lanyards in twelve colors. It costs less, carries 4.6 stars from 2,202 ratings, and solves the same problem of telling cards apart. The trade is count. A family of six is covered either way, but a group of fifteen needs two of those 12-packs, and at that point the Hotop pack's twenty sets look like the simpler order. The 3-pack of clear badge holders, with more than ten thousand bought in a month by its own label, is the answer for a couple or a small family who don't need twenty of anything.

Not one competitor in the table carries a team logo. That is the Michigan strap's whole case, and it is a real one if your recipient bleeds maize and blue.

Small details that matter on the day

Name cards, passes and the Hotop sleeve

The Hotop sleeve is 4.41 by 2.68 inches, and the listing asks you to allow for small errors because it was measured by hand. If you plan to print name cards for a reunion or a group trip, make them a little smaller than the sleeve rather than exactly its size, so they slide in without bending. A buyer's note that the sail and sign cards "fit perfect" tells you the sleeve was cut with a ship card in mind. A folded paper pass or a printed itinerary will need folding to fit, and the clear face means whatever side faces out is the side people read. Put the name or the barcode there.

The patterns help in a way that is easy to miss until the second day. Twenty identical clear sleeves on twenty identical black straps look like a conference. Twenty different prints let a parent spot which child left a card on the pool deck, and let a couple tell their two cards apart on the dresser. One buyer bought them precisely so guests could hold room keys, and called the material smooth rather than scratchy, which counts on a strap worn from breakfast to the late show.

Keys, badges and the Michigan clasp

The Michigan strap is built around the metal clasp. Everything that hangs from it, whether a key ring, a car fob or a work badge, puts weight on that one clip, and the snap buckle above it is plastic. The listing's highlight calls it a breakaway holder for an ID badge and car keys. That design has a sensible logic: the buckle parts before the strap pulls hard on your neck. It also means the buckle and the clasp are the two parts doing the work, and those are exactly the parts the negative reviews name. Keep the load light, a badge and a couple of keys, and the reports suggest it does its job.

After the event

A lanyard is one of the few party purchases that outlasts the party. One Hotop buyer says the straps held up for the whole seven-day voyage and that they can use them again next year. The straps fold small, and a pack that weighs 16 ounces in total won't bother a suitcase. Keep the spares in a zip bag with the sleeves, because the sleeves are what tears first. The Michigan strap, meanwhile, simply becomes the owner's everyday key holder, which is how several of its reviewers describe using it. Neither listing gives a care or washing instruction, so treat both as wipe-clean rather than machine-washable.

Which one fits your occasion

Neither of these is a better lanyard in the abstract. They do different jobs, and the right choice depends on where the strap is going.

OccasionPickWhy
Family cruise, 10 to 20 peopleHotopOne pack covers everyone, sleeves keep cards scannable, patterns tell cards apart
Reunion or group trip with printed name cardsHotopThe 4.41 x 2.68 in sleeve shows the card through clear PVC
Tailgate crew with paper passesHotopSleeves keep tickets dry from splashes; spares cover a lost one
Graduation gift for a Michigan gradMichiganLicensed team gear, logo printed to face out
Everyday keys and a hard work badgeMichiganMetal clasp and snap buckle, but watch the clip
Classroom or very young childrenNeither without careHotop's own listing warns of entanglement risk with little kids

Who should buy the Hotop pack

Buy it if you are the organizer. The person who books the cabins for twenty relatives, or who hands out the season passes before a group bus trip, gets the most out of it. You will want it if your group carries cards that must be scanned or shown, if you like spares in the suitcase, and if assorted patterns sound like a help rather than a mess. A clear stadium tote and a few rain ponchos round out a day outdoors.

Skip it if you need a heavy-duty holder for daily use over months, or if you want every strap in one color for a team look. The listing doesn't let you choose patterns.

Who should buy the Michigan lanyard

Buy it for one Wolverines fan, or for yourself if your keys and badge already live on a lanyard and you'd like it to carry the block M. It makes a tidy add-on to a graduation card or a holiday stocking, and the listing states it is officially licensed, which matters to fans who care where the royalties go.

Skip it if you need to carry a paper ticket or pass without buying a separate sleeve, or if you hang a heavy key ring on it and yank it from a pocket all day. That is the use the broken-clip reports describe. And if you are dressing a whole tailgate in team colors, look at the flags and decor in our football party decor review, or at favors like the ones in our sports party favors roundup, rather than buying six of these.

Verdict

For a group, the Hotop 20-pack is the clear pick. About 90 cents buys each person a strap and a clear sleeve, the quick-release clip earns unanimous praise, and the complaints are honest ones about plastic sleeves that won't last forever. We recommend it for a family cruise, a reunion trip or any day when twenty people need a card on a strap.

The Desert Cactus Michigan lanyard is a pleasant fan gift with a solid star rating, but it has no card sleeve, and six of its nine durability mentions are negative. We recommend it with caveats: buy it for the logo, use it for keys and a badge, and keep an eye on the clasp.

8.3out of 10
We recommend

Buy the Hotop pack for a group, the Michigan strap for one fan

For a cruise, reunion or tailgate crew, the Hotop 20-pack is the pick: a strap and a clear card sleeve per person at well under a dollar a set, with very few complaints. The Desert Cactus Michigan lanyard is a fine single gift for a Wolverines fan, but it carries no card sleeve and its clasp draws most of its complaints.

What works
  • Hotop: 20 straps and 20 clear PVC sleeves for about 90 cents a set
  • Both have a detachable buckle so a card or keys come off without lifting the strap over your head
  • Michigan strap: the listing states it is officially licensed, with the logo printed to face out
What doesn't
  • Michigan strap has no card sleeve, so a ticket or pass needs its own holder
  • Michigan durability mentions run negative: a broken clip and fraying fabric
  • Hotop sleeves are plastic, and a few buyers found one missing or torn
8.0Design
7.5Quality
9.0Size & count
8.5Value
9.0Buyers

Best for: Hotop: a family cruise, a reunion trip or a tailgate crew who all need a card on a strap. Michigan: one Wolverines fan who wants keys and a badge on a team strap.

Skip it if: You need a heavy-duty holder that lasts years of daily use, or you want team colors on all twenty straps.

Check the Hotop pick on Amazon

Where the numbers come from. Prices, star ratings, rating counts and monthly purchase badges were read from the product pages on November 18, 2026; they move daily. Counts, sizes and materials come from the product specifications. Buyer quotes are Amazon reviews as the product page shows them, linked to the full review where Amazon gives one. See how we review.

More game day

The occasion
Game Day & Outdoor EventsAll game day reviewsEvery product we covered there, with price, rating and verdict.Open