Independent reviews for parties, holidays and gifts96 reviews · 252 products · 30 brands

Balloons, favors, holiday decor, gift boxes and the bulk packs behind every party, read before you buy.

Events & CelebrationsThe party review desk
Menu

Costumes & Dress-Up · In-depth review

Amylove frog and carrot dog hoodies: two costumes for a dog of 3 to 4.5 kg

Two hooded costumes in one bag for about $9 each, but only in size M, for dogs the listing puts at 3 to 4.5 kg (about 6.6 to 9.9 lb).

Amylove frog and carrot dog hoodies: two costumes for a dog of 3 to 4.5 kg
Two small dogs wearing the green frog hoodie and the red carrot hoodie.

A dog's first Halloween usually comes down to one photo on the front step. Amylove's answer is a bag with two hooded costumes in it: a green frog with a hood and two legs, and a red carrot with the same cut. Put one on a puppy, and you have the photo. Put both on two small dogs, and you have a better one.

The deciding fact is not the design, which is the cheerful kind that works in a picture, but the size. The listing sells this pair in size M only, "very suitable for pets of 3-4.5 KG". That is about 6.6 to 9.9 pounds, a three-pound window, and the listing gives no chest, neck or back length to check against. If your dog weighs inside that window, the pair is a good buy. If not, this listing has nothing for you.

The price helps the case. At $17.99 for two hoodies, each costume costs about $9 on the day we read it, which is less than any single dog costume in the same search.

Amylove Dog Hoodies Frog & Carrot Shape M Halloween Costume
Amylove

Amylove Dog Hoodies Frog & Carrot Shape M Halloween Costume

4.5 / 5 from 54 ratings

$17.99at our last price check

Check price on Amazon

What is in the bag

The bag holds two pet hoodies, both in size M. One is a green frog style, the other a red carrot style, and each has a hood and two legs. The listing describes the fabric as "quality polyester and cotton", with the detail table saying the same, and the closure as pull-on. The hood stays up with an elastic band that the listing says "can help to fix the hat on the pet's head", and both leg openings have elastic that, in the listing's words, does "not strangle the feet".

The listing's only photo: two small dogs wearing the green frog hoodie and the red carrot hoodie
The listing's only photo: two small dogs wearing the green frog hoodie and the red carrot hoodie

The product page shows just this one photo, of two small dogs side by side, one in each costume. That is less than we would like. There is no flat-lay of the hoodies, no close-up of the hood, and no size chart. The bullets describe a hood and two legs on each costume, which means a sweater-style body with sleeves for the front legs. How long the body is and how far the legs reach, the listing doesn't say.

The detail table gives the product dimensions as 13.39 by 11.02 by 0.63 inches and the weight as 5.29 ounces. A depth of 0.63 inches describes something folded flat, so we read those numbers as the size of the packed bag, not of a hoodie on a dog. Split between two costumes, 5.29 ounces is about 2.6 ounces each, which tells you this is a light layer and not a padded coat.

What you still need

  • A kitchen or bathroom scale to weigh the dog before ordering.
  • A soft tape measure, to compare your dog's chest with a hoodie once it arrives.
  • Treats, because a hood is new to most dogs and the first try goes better with a reward.
  • A second pair of hands for the first fitting, one to hold and one to guide the legs.

The brand adds a note on the product page: "Small items are included, please keep them away from pets in case of choking risk." The listing doesn't say which small items it means, and the photo shows no loose parts on either costume. We read it as a general warning, and the sensible response is the same either way: check each hoodie for anything stitched or glued on that a dog could chew loose, and don't leave a dog alone in a costume.

The size window, translated into dogs

The whole decision rests on weight, so here it is laid out. The listing gives the range in kilograms, and we convert at 2.2 pounds to the kilogram.

Your dog weighsIn poundsWhat the listing says
Under 3 kgunder about 6.6 lbBelow the listed minimum of 3 kg
3 to 4.5 kgabout 6.6 to 9.9 lb"very suitable" for this size M
Over 4.5 kgover about 9.9 lbNot covered; the listing offers no other size

The detail table also lists a minimum weight of 3 kg and a breed size of "Small", which agrees with the bullet. It doesn't give a maximum outside the bullet's 4.5 kg.

Weight is a rough guide to fit, because two dogs of the same weight can be built very differently. A deep-chested dog of 4 kg needs more room around the ribs than a long, slim dog of the same weight, and a fluffy coat adds bulk the scale doesn't count. With no chest measurement on the listing, weight is all you have before the bag arrives. Once it does, measure the hoodie's chest flat, double it, and compare with a tape around your dog just behind the front legs. If the hoodie is snug with a finger's room, it will stay on. If it pulls tight across the chest, the elastic legs will dig in, and the costume will be miserable for the dog and pointless for the photo.

Puppies change the math. A puppy at 3 kg in September may be past 4.5 kg by the end of October, so a first-Halloween puppy is a moving target. Weigh the week you order, and if the puppy is near the top of the window and growing fast, expect the hoodie to fit for the night and not much longer.

Two costumes, two ways to use them

Two hoodies in one bag is the main reason to choose this listing over a single costume. It gives you two different plans.

PlanWho wears whatCost per costume
One dog, two looksFrog for Halloween night, carrot for a spring photo or a garden partyabout $9
Two dogs, one themeFrog on one, carrot on the otherabout $9
One dog, one spareWear one, keep the second for a wash day or a mishapabout $9

The two-dog plan is the one the listing's photo shows, and it is the most fun. A frog and a carrot don't obviously belong together, which is part of the joke: a garden pond and a vegetable patch, side by side on the doorstep. Both dogs need to sit inside the 3 to 4.5 kg window, which happens more often in pairs of the same breed or litter.

The one-dog plan gets the most out of the purchase. The red carrot isn't a strictly Halloween costume, and a carrot in April has an obvious joke to it. The listing itself pitches the set beyond Halloween, saying the hoodies can "dress up your pet dog for various occasions".

The spare plan is underrated. Dogs roll in things, and a costume that gets muddy at four in the afternoon has a replacement by six.

Next year, and the year after

A grown dog that sits in the window this year will likely fit the hoodie again next October, since adult dogs hold their weight better than puppies. That makes the pair a small yearly costume rather than a one-night purchase. Wash both hoodies before storing them, let them dry fully, and fold them flat in a bag with the hood tucked in, so the elastic band isn't stretched over a hanger for eleven months. Check the leg elastic and the hood band each autumn before the first fitting: elastic is the part of a light costume that gives out first, and a slack hood band is what turns a frog back into a sweater.

For a puppy, the second costume can serve as the reason to buy now. If the puppy outgrows the window by spring, a friend's small dog can inherit the carrot, which is not a bad fate for a $9 costume.

Putting it on and keeping it on

The listing describes the hoodie as easy to put on and take off: a pull-on body, two elastic leg openings and an elastic band at the hood. With a pull-on cut like this, the head most likely goes through first, then the front legs one at a time, and then the hood comes up. The listing doesn't say where the hood band sits, under the chin or behind the ears, so check that on the first fitting.

The first try is the hard one. Most dogs tolerate a sweater sooner than a hood, because a hood covers the ears and changes what they hear. Put the body on first and let the dog walk around in it for a minute or two with the hood down. Then raise the hood for a few seconds, reward, and drop it again. A dog that has worn the hoodie three times before Halloween night will hold still for the photo. A dog that sees it for the first time at the door may not.

The brand's own advice on the product page is to "observe the pet's reaction when using" and to "remove the product in time if there is any discomfort". We agree, and we would put it more simply. A dog that freezes, keeps scratching at the hood, or tries to back out of the legs is telling you the costume is done for the day. Take the photo you got and take the hoodie off.

Warmth, shedding and washing

The listing says the hoodies "keep them warm", which a polyester and cotton layer will do a little on a cool October evening. At about 2.6 ounces a hoodie, this is a costume, not a winter coat. It also claims the fabric "can reduce pet hair loss to a certain extent". We have nothing to confirm that with. A hoodie catches loose hair on the inside, which may keep some off the sofa, and that is as far as we would take it.

For cleaning, the listing says only that the hoodies are "easy to clean". It gives no washing instructions, no temperature and no word on the dryer. With polyester and cotton and no care label to go on, a gentle cold wash and air drying is the cautious route, and it protects the elastic in the legs and the hood band, which are the parts most likely to tire.

Candles, porch lights and a dog in fabric

The listing doesn't state that the fabric is flame resistant. The CPSC's Halloween guidance is written for people's costumes, not pets', but its advice on decor applies to any household with a dog underfoot: keep costumes away from open flames, and use flameless, battery-operated lights where they can be reached. A small dog in a hoodie walks at exactly the height of a jack-o'-lantern on the step. If the front-step photo includes a carved pumpkin, light it with a battery candle.

Planning the photo and the night

The listing calls the colors "bright", green for the frog and red for the carrot, and that shapes where the photo works. A green frog on a green lawn disappears into the grass, and a red carrot against a red front door does the same. A plain step, a wooden porch or a pile of orange pumpkins gives both colors something to stand out against. With two dogs, put the frog on the side of the frame with the warmer background and the carrot on the cooler one, so each costume reads.

Timing matters as much as the backdrop. Take the photo before the trick-or-treaters arrive, while the dog is calm and the light is still up, and keep the costume session short. Most of the value of a first-Halloween costume lives in that one picture, and a dog that has worn the hoodie for five relaxed minutes at four o'clock is a better subject than one that has worn it for three hours of doorbells.

For the evening itself, a doorbell, a stream of strangers and a bowl of candy are a lot for a small dog. The hoodie adds warmth on a cold step, which the listing points to, but a dog that is anxious at the door is usually happier out of the costume and in a quiet room.

Order early enough to check the fit

With one size and no measurements, the only real fit check happens when the bag arrives. Order a couple of weeks before Halloween, try the hoodie on within a day or two, and decide while there is still time to send it back and buy a sized costume instead. The listing doesn't state a return policy of its own, so check the terms at checkout before you order.

What buyers say

4.5

54 Amazon ratings

5 star75%
4 star10%
3 star11%
2 star0%
1 star4%

Distribution of Amazon star ratings for the Amylove Dog Hoodies Frog & Carrot Shape M Halloween Costume, read on November 18, 2026.

The pair holds 4.5 stars from 54 ratings. That is a small sample, and we treat it as one. Of those ratings, 75 percent are five-star, 10 percent four-star, 11 percent three-star, none two-star and 4 percent one-star. In people, that is roughly 40 five-star ratings, 5 four-star, 6 three-star and 2 one-star. So about 85 percent of buyers gave four or five stars, and only two or so were unhappy enough for one star.

The product page shows no written buyer comments or topic summaries for this listing, so there is nothing for us to quote. We can't tell you whether the three-star buyers had trouble with sizing, the hood band or the fabric. The star split is the evidence we have, and on 54 ratings it is a good first reading, but not a settled one.

Two things in that split are worth noticing. The one-star share is small, 4 percent, and there are no two-star ratings at all. A costume that badly misfits tends to collect both. The three-star group, at 11 percent, is the larger soft spot, and with a one-size listing our best guess is fit, though the listing gives us no buyer words to prove it. That is one more reason to weigh the dog first.

How it compares

Dog Halloween costumes from the same Amazon search, with price, stars, ratings and monthly sales
ProductPriceRatingRatingsBought last month
Amylove Dog Hoodies Frog & Carrot Shape M Halloween Costume$17.994.554n/a
Pet Deadly Doll Dog Costume$16.994.09041K+
Halloween Dog Bat Wings Costume$9.894.0662700+
Dog Halloween Costumes$12.994.4171600+
Dog Halloween Costumes$9.994.56182K+
Large Dog Halloween Costumes$9.994.53142K+
T2Y Dog Halloween Costumes$17.994.1380600+

Prices, ratings and monthly purchase counts as shown on Amazon search results on November 18, 2026. Highlighted rows are the products reviewed here.

The search for "dog halloween costume" turns up capes, bat wings, a chef outfit, a cowboy rider and character costumes. Most are single costumes, many are sold in several sizes, and several are aimed at large dogs. The Amylove pair is different on both counts: two costumes, one size, small dogs only.

On price per costume, the pair comes out ahead. Two hoodies for $17.99 means each one costs less than every single costume in the table, including the bat wings and the capes, which are simpler pieces that sit on the back rather than covering the body and head. Two dogs dressed from this bag cost less than two of any costume in the table, bought one at a time.

On ratings, the picture is closer. The vampire cape at 4.5 from 618 ratings and the bat wings for large dogs at 4.5 from 314 match the Amylove pair's stars on far more ratings. The chef costume holds 4.4 from 171, the small bat wings 4.0 from 662, the doll costume 4.0 from 904, and the character costume for large dogs 4.1 from 380. So the Amylove pair rates as well as the best of them, but on a sample of 54, where the others have hundreds. Sales tell the same story: several competitors list 1K+ or 2K+ bought in the past month, and the Amylove listing shows no monthly figure.

What the other costumes have that this one lacks is a size range. If your dog is outside 3 to 4.5 kg, the titles of the vampire cape and the chef outfit name small, medium and large dogs, and there are bat wings for both small and large dogs. Those are the obvious alternatives.

Who should buy, who should skip

Buy the frog and carrot pair if your dog weighs between 3 and 4.5 kg, about 6.6 to 9.9 pounds, and you want either two looks for one dog or a matching pair for two. It is the cheapest way in this search to dress a small dog head to tail, and the frog-and-carrot pairing makes a better photo than one costume alone.

Buy it, too, for a small-dog owner as a gift, as long as you know the dog's weight. The listing pitches the set as a present for "family, friends, relatives, colleagues or neighbors who have pets", and two costumes in one bag does make a generous gift at about $9 a costume. Ask the owner the weight first, though. Guessing a dog's weight is how gifts end up in a drawer.

Skip it if your dog is under 3 kg or over 4.5 kg, since there is no other size on this listing. Skip it, too, if your dog dislikes anything on its head, because the hood is half the costume and a frog with the hood down is just a green sweater. And skip it if you need a costume for a larger dog: several costumes in the comparison are sold for large dogs.

For the rest of the household's costumes, see our reviews of crazy wigs, skeleton clips and potion bottles and kids' animal and explorer costume sets, which can turn a frog dog into a whole family theme. More ideas live in the costumes and dress-up category, and Amylove shows the set on its own frog and carrot hoodie page.

Verdict

We recommend the Amylove frog and carrot hoodies with one caveat that matters more than any other: your dog must weigh 3 to 4.5 kg. Inside that window, two costumes for about $9 each, a hood that stays up with an elastic band and a 4.5 star rating make this a good first-Halloween buy. Outside it, there is nothing to fit, and a sized costume from the comparison is the better choice. The listing gives only one photo, no measurements beyond weight and no care instructions, so weigh the dog, check the chest once it arrives, and keep the receipt.

7.6out of 10
Recommended with caveats

Two cute costumes, if your dog sits inside one narrow size

The frog and carrot pair gives a small dog two looks, or two small dogs a matching pair, for about the price of one costume elsewhere. The catch is the size: one size M for dogs of 3 to 4.5 kg, with no chest or back measurement on the listing. Weigh the dog before you buy.

What works
  • Two costumes in one bag, about $9 each at the price on the day we read it
  • Hood with an elastic band and two leg openings with elastic, pulled on like a sweater
  • 4.5 stars, with 85 percent of ratings at four or five stars
What doesn't
  • Only size M, for dogs the listing puts at 3 to 4.5 kg
  • No chest, neck or back length on the listing, only a weight range
  • Small sample of 54 ratings, and no written buyer comments to read on the product page
8.4Design
7.2Quality
7.0Size & count
8.3Value
7.8Buyers

Best for: A small dog's first Halloween photos, or two small dogs who should match.

Skip it if: Your dog weighs under 3 kg or over 4.5 kg, or hates anything over its head.

Check price on Amazon

Where the numbers come from. Prices, star ratings, rating counts and monthly purchase badges were read from the product pages on November 18, 2026; they move daily. Counts, sizes and materials come from the product specifications. See how we review.

More dress-up

The occasion
Costumes & Dress-UpAll dress-up reviewsEvery product we covered there, with price, rating and verdict.Open