Games are the part of a baby shower that hosts dread most. Someone has to pick them, print them, explain them and find pens for forty people who arrived with handbags full of everything except pens. The three sets here take that job off your hands in three different ways, and the one you want depends less on budget than on what kind of afternoon you are planning.
Patelai's set is the full program: a wooden "don't say baby" sign, 50 clothespins, 250 game cards and 20 pencils in a bear and tartan theme. BBTO's set is one game, the dirty diaper game, with a wooden sign and 50 felt diapers on gold pins. COCHIE's set is not really a game at all. It is 26 alphabet coloring pages that guests fill in during the party and that become a bound ABC book for the baby.
What decides it is the shape of the party. A shower with a host who likes to run things wants Patelai's cards. A shower where people mostly chat wants something that runs itself, and both the diaper game and the coloring book do. If the parents care more about what they take home than about who wins, the ABC book is the only one of the three that ends up on a shelf. Prices below are live tokens, and the per-guest sums use the price on the day we read the listings.
Patelai baby shower games: 321 pieces in a bear and tartan theme

Baby Shower Games, pack of 321
$32.99at our last price check
What is in the box
Patelai counts 321 pieces, and the bullets break that down: 1 wooden "don't say baby" sign, 50 wooden clothespins, 250 baby shower cards and 20 pencils. The design is a "We Can Bearly Wait" theme in blue and green tartan, with a rocking horse, balloons and a checkered brown bear. The listing names it a luxury equestrian bear theme, which is a mouthful for a set that mostly looks like a nursery quilt.
The sign is given as about 5.12 by 7.87 by 0.2 inches, so roughly the size of a paperback cover, and the description says it "can stand firmly on the tables". The clothespins are where the listing contradicts itself: the bullets give them as about 1.38 by 0.28 inches, while the specification lists 1.54 by 0.79 inches. Both describe a small clip, and the listing adds that its sizes are measured by hand.


All told, the set weighs 1.8 pounds and its item dimensions are 10.04 by 6.3 by 2.17 inches. That is a box you can carry to a venue under one arm. Cards are paper and the sign, pins and pencils are wood, according to the detail table.
What the listing does not say is which games the 250 cards hold or how many cards each game gets. The description says only that you play "according to the rules on the wood sign and cards". At 50 guests, 250 cards works out to five cards per guest, which suggests five games of 50 sheets each, but treat that as arithmetic rather than a promise. Open the box when it arrives and sort the cards into piles before the morning of the party.
Running the afternoon
The clothespin game is the backbone. Each guest clips a pin to her top on arrival, and anyone caught saying the banned word gives her pin to whoever caught her. The sign tells newcomers the rule, which saves you from explaining it 40 times at the door. With 50 pins, a shower of 35 leaves 15 spare for the guests who arrive after the coffee.
Then come the cards. They hang neatly, as the dessert-table photo shows, strung above the cake rather than in a stack on a side table. The bear and tartan print matches the sign and the pins, so the games read as part of the decoration even before anyone picks up a pencil.


Pace the cards rather than handing out every game at once. One game while people arrive, one after gifts, one with cake keeps the pencils circulating and gives the quieter guests a second and third chance to win something. It also means fewer sheets abandoned on chairs, which is where most party games end up when they are dealt out in a single pile.
Pencils are the weak spot. Twenty pencils for 50 clothespins means two and a half guests per pencil if everybody plays at once. At a shower of 30 that leaves ten people waiting or digging through handbags, and one buyer put it in five words:
Great games, just not enough pencilsAmazon buyer
A box of pencils from the office drawer fixes it. Count your guests, subtract 20, and bring the difference.
The second weak spot is the printing. Of the 7 topics buyers raise, "typing errors" is the only one that is entirely negative: 40 mentions, none of them kind. Some buyers just roll their eyes, and some are angry. One reports glaring spelling and grammar errors on every game, plus broken clothespins. Forty out of thousands of ratings is a minority, but it is a loud one, so read the cards the day the box comes, while there is still time to cross out a mistake with a pen or reorder.
Getting it ready the night before
A set this size rewards an hour at the kitchen table. Sort the cards by game into separate piles, clip a rubber band round each, and stack them in the order you plan to play. Put the 50 clothespins in a bowl next to the sign, so the first guest through the door takes one without being told. If you plan to hang some of the cards as decoration, as the listing photo does, decide which game they belong to before you string them up, or you will be unpinning them mid-party.
This is also the moment to read every card. Typos are easier to fix with a pen at home than to explain while forty people hold the sheet. And check the clothespins, since one buyer found several broken or falling apart. A pin with a loose bear can be glued tonight, or simply left in the box.
Theme is the last check. Tartan, a rocking horse and a brown bear work for a boy shower, a gender-neutral one or a "teddy bear" theme. They look out of place at a pink floral party, and Patelai sells other designs for that, judging by the themes its buyers describe.
What buyers say
Patelai's set holds 4.8 stars from 3,063 ratings, and 88 percent are five stars. One- and two-star ratings together make up 2 percent. That is the strongest record in this roundup and one of the strongest we see on any party game.
One thing to know about the buyer comments: they mention strawberry, safari, dinosaur, elephant, "Baby is Brewing" and "berry sweet" themes, pink bow clothespins and butterflies. The bear set is one design among many, and the ratings and comments appear to be shared across Patelai's other themes. That is useful for judging the format, less so for judging this exact print.
Games were great and made set up and clean up so much easier.Amazon buyer
“Used this for my sister's baby shower & it was fun and so worth it if you are a busy person who do not have time to come up with games yourself.”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“…The pink bow clothes pins were just the cutest! Came with pencils so no need to run around the house looking for something to write with.…”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Perfect for my “Baby is Brewing” baby shower! The paper is on the thinner side, but should be fine for a few hours! Would recommend”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Cute but game sheets have typos! It’s frustrating”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“…Every game had glaring spelling and grammar errors, and several of the clothespins were broken or falling apart.…”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
Read the five cards above as a fair sample. The praise is about the time saved and the clothespins. The criticism is about thin paper (one buyer says it should be fine for a few hours), typos and, once, broken pins. The topic table below puts numbers on it: quality comes up 205 times, 174 of them positive and 31 negative, and value comes up 95 times, 82 positive and 13 negative.
| Topic | Reviews that mention it | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality | 205 | 174 | 31 (15%) |
| Gameplay | 122 | 122 | 0 (0%) |
| Value for money | 95 | 82 | 13 (14%) |
| Baby shower-friendly | 51 | 51 | 0 (0%) |
| Included accessories | 50 | 47 | 3 (6%) |
| Ease of use | 29 | 28 | 1 (3%) |
| Typing errors | 40 | 0 | 40 (100%) |
Topic counts as Amazon groups them on the product page, read November 18, 2026.
Patelai also sells the set on its own site, on the Patelai product page.
BBTO dirty diaper game: one sign and 50 felt diapers

51 Pcs Dirty Diaper Wooden Game Sign Baby Shower
$13.99at our last price check
What is in the box
BBTO's set is narrower. It holds 1 wooden game sign, 50 blue felt diapers and 50 gold pins, 51 pieces by the title's count if you leave the pins out. The listing says it serves 50 guests. The sign is the same 5.12 by 7.87 by 0.2 inches as Patelai's and has a holder on the back so it stands on a table. The felt diapers measure about 5.5 by 4.7 inches unfolded, and each gold pin is about 1.1 inches long.
The theme is safari animals with green leaves. The listing says the sign is printed with instruction words so guests can understand how to play at once, but it doesn't reproduce the rules in its text, and it calls the diapers prizes for winners. So the sign carries the game, and the diapers are what guests win or wear. The set weighs 7 ounces and ships in a package of 9.49 by 5.59 by 1.69 inches.


Pins are the part to watch. The description ends with its own warning, in the brand's words: "The pointed parts may include, please use it carefully."
That is a gold pin, sharp at one end, on a small felt diaper. At a shower with toddlers in the room, keep the bag of spares on a high shelf. The CPSC holiday safety tips say to keep small items and toys with small parts away from children younger than 3, and both a pin and a 5-inch felt diaper qualify as things a small child should not be handed.
How it plays
Because it is one game, it suits a shower where nobody wants a program. You put the sign on the gift table or by the door, hand each guest a diaper and a pin, and let the sign do the talking. At about 28 cents a guest at the price on the day we read it, it costs less than any other set here, and 50 diapers covers a large living-room shower with room for a few extra.
Its photos show how it looks set out: a single wooden sign with a fan of small blue diapers around it, on a rustic table or next to a vase. Blue felt reads as boy to most guests, which is worth knowing if the baby is a girl or still a surprise. The listing doesn't offer other colors on this page.
The listing also suggests using the set as table decor, and that is a fair second life for it. A wooden sign and a ring of small felt diapers look at home on the gift table, so even guests who skip the game see it. After the shower, felt and wood pack flat into the original bag, ready for the next baby in the family.


What buyers say
Here the record is thin. The set holds 4.3 stars from only 28 ratings, so a single unhappy buyer moves the average. Seventy percent are five stars, but 13 percent are two stars, about four people out of 28. That is above the level where we would normally go looking for the reason, and here we can't: the listing carries no buyer excerpts and no topic counts. We can say the sample is small and the two-star share is real, and that is all.
If you want the dirty diaper game in particular, this is a cheap way to try it. Just don't treat 4.3 stars from 28 people as the same kind of evidence as Patelai's 4.8 from 3,063. BBTO lists the same set on the BBTO product page.
COCHIE Baby's First ABC Book: 26 coloring pages that turn into a keepsake

Baby's First ABC Book Baby Shower Game Coloring Card
$9.99at our last price check
What is in the box
COCHIE's set holds 1 table sign, 26 A to Z alphabet coloring pages, 1 book cover and 8 book rings. Each page carries a letter and an animal for guests to color. Once everyone is done, the rings bind the pages into a book the parents keep. The listing describes the pages and the sign as sturdy cardstock and states that markers will not bleed through.
Setup is light. You stick the paper holder on the back of the table sign so it stands, lay the pages out beside it and let guests pick a letter. The package measures 9.45 by 7.44 by 0.67 inches and weighs 6.7 ounces, so the whole thing fits in a tote bag with room for the cake knife.


The sizes appear only on the chart photo. The text of the listing doesn't state the page size, and two buyers say the finished book is smaller than they expected. Look at that chart before you order, and picture a board book rather than a coffee-table album.
Markers are not included. One buyer says plainly that the set is "only the cards", and the included-items list confirms it. Bring your own, and pick them with care, because the one practical tip in the buyer comments is about exactly that.
Use pen markers not regular markers or they smudgeAmazon buyer
That tip sits awkwardly next to the listing's statement that markers will not bleed through. Bleeding through the card and smudging on top of it are two different problems, so both can be true. Fine-tip pens are the safer choice.
How it fits the party
Twenty-six pages means 26 guests get a letter each. At a shower of 20, six letters are left for the parents or a sibling to finish later. At a shower of 40, fourteen guests have nothing to color unless pairs share a page. That makes this a corner activity rather than a game for everyone, the quiet table where guests drift between gifts and cake.
A simple way to hand out letters: put the 26 pages in a basket face down and let each guest draw one on arrival. Nobody argues over the elephant, and you can see at a glance how many letters are still waiting. If a family wants the parents' own initials colored by someone close, pull those two pages out first and hand them over in person. That small piece of planning is what turns a table of loose cards into a book that feels made for this baby.
It also works with children. One buyer says it "kept the kids at the baby shower busy", and coloring is one of the few shower activities a seven-year-old enjoys as much as her aunt does. The photos show adults at it too: guests holding up finished cards, and the bound book standing on its sign beside a cup of markers.
Binding is the last step, and it is easy to rush. Eight rings hold 26 pages and a cover, so wait until every page is dry before you thread them, especially if guests used markers. The listing doesn't say how many holes each page has or whether the rings open wide enough for the cover, so try one ring on two pages before the party ends. Letters nobody colored can go home blank for the parents to fill in later, which some families will like better than a finished book.



What buyers say
The set holds 4.4 stars from 62 ratings, with 74 percent at five stars and 8 percent at one or two. It also shows "100+ bought in past month", the only purchase figure among the three. Every topic buyers raise is positive: fun comes up 11 times, appearance 9 and quality 8, with no negative mentions in any of them.
“Really cute. Very fun activity and kept the kids at the baby shower busy.”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“It was a little smaller than expected but a fabulous baby shower activity for the baby to keep forever!”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“So adorable and fun to do! Use pen markers not regular markers or they smudge”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“…I am saving it for my baby when he’s old so he can color them but they’re so cute . It’s only the cards tho”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
“Book looked so cute but didnt come in time for the baby shower i was so looking forward to this.…”
Read the full review on Amazon. Excerpt as shown on the product page.
Where complaints appear, they are practical rather than about the product failing. The book is smaller than some expected, markers aren't in the box, regular markers smudge, and one buyer's order arrived after the shower. Order early. COCHIE sells the set on the COCHIE product page.
| Topic | Reviews that mention it | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fun | 11 | 11 | 0 (0%) |
| Appearance | 9 | 9 | 0 (0%) |
| Quality | 8 | 8 | 0 (0%) |
Topic counts as Amazon groups them on the product page, read November 18, 2026.
Costs and guest counts side by side
All three sets are sold by the box, but they cover different numbers of guests. Per-guest costs use the prices on the day we read the listings.
| Set | Price | Guests covered | Cost per guest | What you still need |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patelai 321-piece games | $32.99 | 50 | about 66 cents | more pencils |
| BBTO dirty diaper game | $13.99 | 50 | about 28 cents | nothing named in the listing |
| COCHIE ABC book | $9.99 | 26 | about 38 cents | fine-tip pens or markers |
The second table shows what each set does at common guest counts, so you can see where one box runs out.
| Guests | Patelai | BBTO | COCHIE |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 | 35 spare pins, 5 spare pencils | 35 spare diapers | 11 pages left for family |
| 26 | 24 spare pins, 6 guests short of a pencil | 24 spare diapers | one page each, none spare |
| 40 | 10 spare pins, 20 short of a pencil | 10 spare diapers | 14 guests without a page |
| 50 | all pins used, 30 short of a pencil | all diapers used | 24 guests without a page |
Pencils are the column hosts forget. Patelai's box is generous everywhere except the one thing every card game needs.
| Patelai Baby Shower Games, pack of 321 | BBTO 51 Pcs Dirty Diaper Wooden Game Sign Baby Shower | COCHIE Baby's First ABC Book Baby Shower Game Coloring Card | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $32.99 | $13.99 | $9.99 |
| Amazon rating | 4.8 (3,063) | 4.3 (28) | 4.4 (62) |
| Item Weight | 1.8 pounds | 7 ounces | 6.7 ounces |
| Package Dimensions | n/a | 9.49 x 5.59 x 1.69 inches | 9.45 x 7.44 x 0.67 inches |
Read across the spec table and the difference is clear. Patelai and BBTO share the same 5.12 by 7.87 inch wooden sign, and both are built around a pin or clip each guest wears. COCHIE has no game mechanics at all, just pages, a cover and rings. Two of the sets ask guests to compete, and the third asks them to make something.
What to have on hand whatever you pick
None of the three boxes is the whole kit. Patelai's set needs more pencils, as covered above. COCHIE's needs fine-tip pens, and the buyer advice points away from ordinary felt markers. BBTO's needs nothing beyond the box to play, but a few safety pins of your own make a useful backup if any gold ones go missing between the door and the sofa.
Prizes are your call. None of the listings includes a prize for the winner, except that BBTO's listing calls its diapers prizes. A small favor works, and so does giving the winner first pick of the cake. Guests remember who won the clothespin game far longer than what she won.
Finally, think about where each set sits. Patelai's sign wants the entrance, where guests collect a pin. COCHIE's book wants a table with chairs and good light. BBTO's sign can go anywhere a guest will see it on the way to the drinks.
How they compare with other shower games
The same Amazon search for baby shower games turned up a wide shelf, from a pin-the-pacifier poster to Loteria and blindfolded feeding games. The table shows prices, ratings and sales for the closest alternatives.
| Product | Price | Rating | Ratings | Bought last month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patelai Baby Shower Games, pack of 321 | $32.99 | 4.8 | 3,063 | n/a |
| BBTO 51 Pcs Dirty Diaper Wooden Game Sign Baby Shower | $13.99 | 4.3 | 28 | n/a |
| COCHIE Baby's First ABC Book Baby Shower Game Coloring Card | $9.99 | 4.4 | 62 | 100+ |
| ADJOY Pin The Pacifier - Baby Shower Party Favors and Game | $7.99 | 4.7 | 10,329 | 1K+ |
| Kate Aspen Baby Predictions for Baby Shower Advice Cards - 50-Count… | $11.99 | 4.8 | 2,035 | 800+ |
| Baby Shower Games Kit | $20.99 | 4.6 | 131 | 200+ |
| 78 PCS Fun Baby Shower Games Sign Kit | $31.99 | 4.5 | 682 | 1K+ |
| Baby Shower Loteria Fiesta Mexican Game - Bilingual English Spanish | $14.90 | 4.8 | 879 | 300+ |
| Bibs Bodysuits Baby Shower Game Sign Set Newborn Onesies Feeder Gift… | $36.99 | 4.8 | 204 | 200+ |
Prices, ratings and monthly purchase counts as shown on Amazon search results on November 18, 2026. Highlighted rows are the products reviewed here.
ADJOY's Pin the Pacifier is the best-known name on the shelf, with 4.7 stars from 10,329 ratings and 1K+ bought in the past month, and it costs less than any of our three. It is a single game, though, closer to BBTO's set than to Patelai's. Kate Aspen's 50 onesie-shaped prediction cards rate 4.8 from 2,035 buyers and also cost less than Patelai. Like COCHIE's book, they turn into something the parents keep, in this case advice cards rather than a book.
The 9-game kit for 50 guests is the most direct rival to Patelai. It costs less, holds 4.6 stars, and has 131 ratings against Patelai's 3,063. The 78-piece sign kit with baby blocks costs about the same as Patelai, rates 4.5 from 682 buyers and shows 1K+ bought. The bilingual Loteria set plays up to 40 and rates 4.8 from 879, which makes it the pick if your family plays in English and Spanish. The onesie stencil kit costs more than anything here and is a craft table rather than a game.
What the table says overall: Patelai's 4.8 from 3,063 is matched on the shelf only by the cheap single games and the prediction cards. Nothing else in the search bundles this many games with a theme for 50 guests. The question is whether its typo record bothers you more than a thinner kit with fewer ratings would.
For the rest of the shower, our shower favors roundup covers pacifier necklaces, parents-to-be pins and keychain favors, and our baby shower decor roundup covers backdrops and wall decals.
Which one for which shower
| Your shower | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Host-led afternoon of games, 30 to 50 guests | Patelai | clothespin game plus 250 cards in one theme |
| Mostly chatting, one game in the background | BBTO | one sign, one rule, 50 diapers |
| Parents want a keepsake | COCHIE | 26 pages bind into a book |
| Children in the room | COCHIE | coloring suits kids; no pins |
| Tight budget, big guest list | BBTO | about 28 cents a guest |
| Girl shower or a surprise | Patelai or COCHIE | BBTO's diapers are blue |
The sets also combine. A host running Patelai's games can set up COCHIE's book as a side table for the guests who would rather color than compete. That pairing costs more than either alone but covers both kinds of guest. BBTO and Patelai overlap more, since both are built around something pinned or clipped on each guest, so we would pick one of the two.
Who should buy each, and who should skip
Buy Patelai's set if you want the games handled in one box, your guest list is between 30 and 50, and you are happy to bring pencils and check the cards on arrival. It is the easiest way here to fill an afternoon. Skip it if a printed typo would ruin the day for you or the guest of honour, because 40 buyers say they found some.
BBTO's set is for a shower that wants one simple game and a low price, run by a host who doesn't mind a small rating record. Skip it if young children will be in the room and nobody can keep an eye on the pins, or if blue doesn't fit the theme.
COCHIE's book suits the parents who care about the keepsake, a shower of around 26 or fewer, or a party with children who need something to do. Skip it if you have 40 guests who all want to take part, or if you were picturing a large book: the buyers who mention size say it came out smaller than they imagined.
For more shower and birthday ideas, the Birthdays & Baby Showers section collects our other reviews in this area.
Verdict
Patelai's set is the most complete and the best-rated, with 4.8 stars from 3,063 buyers and a full program of games for 50 guests at about 66 cents each. Its faults are specific and fixable: too few pencils, thin-ish paper, and a typo record that 40 buyers raise. Check the cards and bring pencils, and it does its job.
COCHIE's ABC book is the one with a life after the party, and its buyers say only good things about the fun and the look. It is smaller than people expect, it covers 26 guests and it needs your own fine pens. BBTO's diaper game is cheap and simple, but 28 ratings with 13 percent at two stars is too little to recommend it without a caveat.
We recommend Patelai's set for a host who wants the games done, and COCHIE's book with caveats as a keepsake corner. We recommend BBTO's set only with caveats, for a budget shower with no toddlers near the pins.
Patelai for the games, COCHIE for the keepsake
Patelai's set runs a whole afternoon of games for about 66 cents a guest and rates 4.8 stars from 3,063 buyers, but 40 of them flag typos on the cards. COCHIE's ABC book leaves the parents a keepsake for 26 guests. BBTO's diaper game is cheap and simple, with a rating sample too small to lean on.
- Patelai gives 50 guests a clothespin, a sign and 250 cards for about 66 cents each
- COCHIE's 26 pages bind into a book the parents keep
- BBTO covers 50 guests for about 28 cents each
- 40 Patelai buyers mention typos on the game cards
- Patelai sends 20 pencils for 50 guests, and COCHIE sends no markers
- BBTO has only 28 ratings, 13 percent of them two stars
Best for: Hosts who want the games sorted in one box: Patelai for a full program, COCHIE for a quieter keepsake corner.
Skip it if: You will proofread nothing and mind a typo on a printed card, or your guest list is far past 50.
Where the numbers come from. Prices, star ratings, rating counts and monthly purchase badges were read from the product pages on November 18, 2026; they move daily. Counts, sizes and materials come from the product specifications. Buyer quotes are Amazon reviews as the product page shows them, linked to the full review where Amazon gives one. See how we review.




